Best Value Shiraz Tasting Results 2019

The top five wines from the inaugural Best Value Shiraz Tastings 2019 have been released.

Seeking to find the best examples of Shiraz between the R60 and R120 price points, the wines were tasted blind by our three judges: Joanne Gibson, Ndaba Dube and Trizanne Barnard with scoring done according to the 100-point quality scale.

Shiraz is something of a chameleon grape, capable of producing wines ranging from fairly light and fresh (even austere) to rich and ripe (even jammy). Producers often claim that their use of the name ‘Syrah’ indicates wines made in the more elegant ‘Rhone’ style rather than the blockbuster ‘Aussie’ style, but this is definitely not always the case. Generally speaking, though, South African Shiraz does sit somewhere in between the two extremes.

From Darling to Devon Valley, Tulbagh to Worcester, the Cape winelands were well represented, and it came as no surprise to discover that our top wine was from the Swartland, home to over a fifth of South Africa’s Shiraz vineyards.


The top five #BestValue wines, at this price point, are as follows:

  1. Lammershoek The Innocent Syrah 2017 – 90/100
  2. Stellenrust Shiraz 2017 –  90/100
  3. Bruce Jack Shiraz 2018 – 89/100
  4. Guardian Peak Shiraz 2018 – 89/100
  5. Robertson Winery Shiraz 2018 – 89/100


To read the full tasting article including key findings, tasting notes for the top five and scores on the 100-point quality scale.  

Join the conversation and follow the action on twitter #BestValue

Have you tried one of these wine? let me know in the comments.

Chat Soon

Facebook Comments

No Comments

Post A Comment

%d bloggers like this: